
What if someone has to tear this house down in a hundred years because it wasn't maintained or built properly? Where does all the drywall and plywood go? How much can ever be re-used?
OK. OK. I know that we never build with the intentions of ever destroying the structure, but that's a reality now. Materials only last so long, tastes change, needs change, and eventually the dirt it's sitting on will be worth more than the shabby structure.
Where I live, there isn't a junk-yard for about a hundred miles; so, if you have an old car or boat or camper you don't want anymore - it is now very inconvenient to get rid of. Therefore, people tend to take care of what they have - handing it down instead of throwing it away.
Money for nothin'
What if someday there was no place to take a dumpster full of old building materials? I bet one of those 10,000 square foot trophy homes in Plano, Texas would take up quite a bit of space in the landfill if it had to come down (or fell down). Right now it is much too easy to haul our waste to a hole in the ground and say goodbye to it "forever". When a house is being built, there is usually a dumpster on site to haul away all of the scrap pieces of drywall and plywood, bits of 2x4's and empty buckets of paint. The bigger the house, the more waste.
Maybe we shouldn't build so big, and maybe we shouldn't use materials that will never return to the earth. Fiberglass insulation and spray foam work great, but they are far from bio-degradable.
Jay Schafer's Tumbleweed Houses are about as big as my kitchen, yet have been so completely planned and designed that they now define space efficiency in a home. Structured around the premise that "less is more", building a Tumbleweed House probably creates about one trash bag full of waste while the Plano trophy home created multiple dumpsters full.